11-08-2019 07:01 AM - edited 11-08-2019 07:19 AM
I have a x1 2018 version bought last November. I have taken care of it very well, but I just found a dead pixel on the screen last week. I made the call to the service and sent it to them. But they just called me and told me the repair is not covered by the warranty because they determined that the damage was made by the customer (CID). The cost of repair is more than $300. My x1 has a 3-year limited warranty.
Here, I wanna ask for the community or anyone that may meet a similar situation before. How did they believe that the damage is made by me but not a problem of their own product? I am a Thinkpad lover of more than 10 years and it is the first time they refuse to fix a screen and said it is my problem.
Thanks all. I attached the pic of the dead pixel here for your reference. Do you guys believe that such a tiny dead pixel can be made by a big guy?
11-08-2019 07:53 AM - edited 11-08-2019 07:55 AM
Often, a dead pixel is considered "normal", but the decision is subjective, based on how noticeable it is. You can get a 2nd opinion. For subjective screen issues (dead or hot pixels, too dim, etc.), I always carry the machine into a repair facility, preferably a Premier Dealer, who does warranty work. I say that I only want to do the repair if it is covered. I ask them to look at it with me, so we are looking at the same thing. If the dealer decides it isn't covered, he doesn't get paid. At the depot, if the guy decides it is covered, it simply means more work for him.
11-08-2019 08:48 AM
Hi. Thanks a lot. If I understand it correctly, you mean going to the service center in person may have higher possibility to get a free repair? Because people there will get paid by the number of repair?
11-08-2019 09:51 AM
Yes. Also, it is easier to discuss the problem if both of you are looking at the same thing.
11-08-2019 04:47 PM
If the "stuck" pixel was on the panel when the system was new, it still would not be covered under warranty because there is a tolerance of 2 or less pixels (could be as much as 5) on the panels. Of course, there is the subjective issue of where the pixel is located, but usually it's because it is dead center in the panel. I don't believe that you could possibly cause a pixel to be stuck "on" so the service center was probably wrong in this regard unless there was physical damage to the screen. There are some programs that sometimes can unstick a stuck pixel, but they are not alway reliable. If the $300 for the panel replacement is less than 50% of a new system, then I would proceed with the repair. Just my two cents here.
11-09-2019 06:56 AM