Support in other languages: 
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Do you mean 
Welcome to the Lenovo Community

Welcome to the Forums!

Welcome to Lenovo's Peer-to-Peer Discussion Community!
Please note our guidelines. How to register and login and Community FAQs.
Shape the Future of PCs

Help Lenovo Shape the Future of PCs

Take the ownership survey. Share your ideas with our product team
Community Spotlight

Visit the Lenovo Blogs!

Check out the ThinkPad Time Machine
Visit the Community Spotlight Blog
Windows  10

Are you ready for Windows 10?

Get to know Windows 10
Visit the Windows 10 Support Center
Reply
Serial Port
Posts: 31
Registered: ‎11-10-2010
Location: WI
0 Kudos
Accepted Solution

Performance - Software RAID 1 vs Hardware RAID 1 on TD230

[ Edited ]

Wondering how the performance of the on-board RAID controller is compared to a RAID card?  In the past I've always used a third party RAID controller card [Promise SuperTrak].

 

I've been considering getting a TD230 [1st time purchase] and using the on-board RAID for a customer with about 30 accounting users.

 

What has your experience been with on-board RAID?

 

Thanks!

 

Al

 

Posts: 5,215
Solutions: 569
Registered: ‎11-23-2007
Location: United States
0 Kudos

Re: Performance - Software RAID 1 vs Hardware RAID 1 on TD230

[ Edited ]

many times onboard RAID will be faster than a discreet RAID card since the onboard utilizes your system's CPU and memory (both of which are faster than most discreet cards).

 

i used discreet RAID in servers for 15+ years before getting onboard RAID in my thinkstation (which has both an intel ICH9R and LSI 1068E chipset).   in three years i haven't had a single issue with SAS drives on the LSI controller.   in fact, i'd say the only limitations are the lack of BBU and the inability to do live migrations—neither of which have proven to be an issue for me over the years.   i haven't used the intel ICHR but can't say i've read about any major problems on this forum or anywhere else on the web.   intel's RAID solution seems quite stable.

 

 

(edit: typo)

ThinkStation C20      ThinkPad X1C · X220 · X60T · 600Microsoft MVP